10 Best Weed Killers Review (July, 2019)

If you’ve ever tried to cultivate a lawn – whether it be your own or someone else’s – you know that it’s hard work.

Not only do you have to assess what kind of landscaping you’re allowed to do in your area, but you have to take into account the type of soil and ecology you’ll be working within. 

Even then, though, your work isn’t done. Your outdoor lawn may look picture perfect, but then you’ll have to contend with the grasses and weeds that pop up over the course of spring and summer.

While not all weeds are vicious, there are several types that are resilient and that resist you when you try plucking them up by the roots. When it comes to these stubborn types of invaders, you have to find the best weed killers for your lawn. You’ll also want to make sure that the product you make use of is – save for the weed-killing element – environmentally safe for you to use.

Weed killers will vary in every lawn. For people who love their beautiful, green fields of grass, solutions to a weed infestation will differ than those for people who’ve cultivated a flower-based or tree-oriented landscape. In order to find the best weed killer for your lawn, take into account not only your environment but the capabilities of the weed killers you’re considering. The last thing you want to do is buy the first product you see and have it destroy all of your hard work!

Weed in your lawn - Lets kill weeds.

BEST VALUE
Southern Ag Amine Weed Killer
SOUTHREN AG2,4-D
  • Selective
  • Contact
  • Post-emergent
  • Low, economical use rate
  • broadleaf weeds, woody plants
Also Consider
Ortho GroundClear Vegetation Killer Concentrate
ORTHO GROUNDCLEAR
  • Non-selective
  • Systemic
  • Post- and Pre-emergent
  • Kills weeds
  • Kills unwanted vegetation

Weed Killers – Buying Guide

So what are the differences between weed killers?

You can identify the differences by looking at their ingredients lists, but most of the time weed killers will advertise the various ways in which they’ll interact with your lawn. Generally speaking, though, there are two primary categories. These categories divide all brands into pre-emergent and post-emergent.

Preemergent weed killers target weeds before they’ve sprouted, working in the soil in order to prevent the formation of wide-spread root networks that could help the weeds sprout back up after they’ve started to grow. Those that are pre-emergent are, as such, great for weed prevention. Comparatively, post-emergent weed killers target weeds that have already sprouted in your lawn and that are large enough for you to see. You can sometimes use these two different categories together in order to more effectively remove weeds from your lawn. Keep in mind, though, that you’ll need to keep the composition of your soil in mind as you apply these products – too much exposure may see damage to the plants you want to keep around!

There are further divisions in the weed killers available to you. Let’s take a look at a few:

Contact and Systemic

Contact weed killers effectively kill any weeds that they physically make contact with and are loved for their ability to work quickly. Annual weeds, such as bindweed, crabgrass, mallow and nettle, are easy to take care of with contact varieties, because they’re spread by seeds that stay above the soil before they sprout. This kind can easily take care of the seeds, making sure they won’t even take root. These kinds will generally show results within hours, which can be very satisfying to watch. You will have to clean up the remains of the weeds you kill with contact weed killers, though – and when you do, make sure you keep your hands safe in your gloves! While contact varieties won’t hurt you, you’ll still want to handle the weeds you’ve killed with care. Weed killer concentrates can vary and will, in turn, the products will behave differently.

Systemic weed killers, on the other hand, actually work their way into the root system, killing the whole plant. This, as we’ve mentioned, ensures that the whole interconnected weed growth you’re seeing in your lawn will wither. Systemic weed killers don’t have the speed of contact weed killers, though. These weed killers usually start showing results within one to three weeks. Perennial weeds, such as bindweed, poison ivy, thistle, ragweed and dandelion, are most likely to need this method, though, as systemic weed killers will make it harder for these plants to continue popping up year after year.

If both of these weed killers sound up your alley, you’re in luck. Some of the weed killers are both systemic and contact. These can be helpful if you’re dealing with an infestation, or you just want to make sure you get everything.

Selectivity

You also have the opportunity to shop around for weed killers based on their selectivity, or the ability of their chemical compositions to target specific plants. Selectivity is important to consider both in terms of the weeds you’re trying to kill and when debating the overall preferred health of your lawn. A Nonselective weed killer, for example, will undoubtedly help you get rid of the weeds that are plaguing you, but it will also kill just about every other plant in your lawn, only potentially excluding your grass. You’re not in the market for grass killers, after all, just weed control. Non-selective types are, in this sense, a last resort for many landscapers, as they can undo your hard work and compromise the safety of your soil for an extended period of time.

Comparably, selective weed killers tend to target only specific plants, as their chemical make up will allow them to leave other plants alone. Selective weed killers are easier on most common types of lawn grass and cultivated flora. The selectivity makes it easier to treat weeds without worrying about the rest of your lawn. However, you should always check the label, as some popular plants, such as St. Augustine grass, may be killed even by selective weed killers.

Combinations

As we mentioned, though, you can combine products of different chemical make ups in order to achieve the best look for your lawn. For example, if you just have a grass lawn with a decent amount of weeds, many non-selective kinds will avoid killing grass, making them a great option for grass-only lawns. If you’re growing vegetables, or you have flowers and decorative plants, a selective weed killer may work. You may also have to be sure not to touch the ones that you want to survive. Make sure you do your research, though! Some products, with their varying chemical combinations, will not work well with each other, may counteract each other, and can, in some cases, decimate your lawn. Move with care when working with multiple types of weed killers, then, and do keep in mind that whatever one you use will leave chemical traces behind in your soil, potentially compromising the health of your more beautiful foliage in the future.

With all of that potential in mind, we can take a look at the most important part of this buying guide. Here are the top ten weed killers that you can buy on Amazon today.

10 Best Weed Killers of 2019

1. Compare-N-Save – Best Non-Selective Weeds Killer

Compare N Save Grass and Weed Killer

  • Non-selective, contact and systemic, for use with post-emergent weeds.

If you have an intense, long-lasting, and otherwise unconquerable weed infestation on your hands, you really can’t go wrong with a product like Compare-N-Save (effective weed killer). This product is effectively the king pin of lawn treatment aids. It uses an extremely powerful 41% glyphosate solution to wipe out anything it touches.

Compare-N-Save works by attacking both the exterior of the plants it comes into contact with and the root systems. Its chemical formula moves through the physiology of the plant in order to destroy the connections between the weed you initially spray and others that have grown alongside it. Whether they’re annual or perennial, whether they’re new or you’ve been dealing with them for years — Compare-N-Save will take it down, and leave you with nothing but grass. It’s worth noting that this effectiveness makes Compare-N-Save an excellent last resort. Because the concentration is so powerful, there is the possibility that you may do irreversible damage to your lawn if you overuse this weed killer.

That concentration is, though, one of Compare-N-Save’s selling points. You can get a massive amount out of a relatively small bottle, which means you save money and time in the long run. Generally speaking, one bottle of Compare-N-Save should enable you to cover between 6,300 to 63,000 square feet of lawn. You should note, however, that with more stubborn or long-lasting weeds, you may have to up the percentage of concentrate.

Pros
  • Affordable
  • Highly concentrated- so you can make a lot of weed killer
  • Effective for both annual and perennial weeds sprayer
  • Kill weeds
Cons
  • Can take up to two hours to become waterproof.
  • Some experimentation may be required with the concentrate percentage.

Buy COMPARE-N-SAVE

2. Southern Ag 2,4-D Amine – Best Selective Broadleaf

Southern Ag 2.4 D-Amine Weed Killer

  • Selective, contact, for use with post-emergent weeds.

You may be wanting a weed killer that’s selective with the plants it works against if you have a lawn that is already full of beautiful foliage. That’s what products like Ag 24d Amine are best at. Some selective kinds will kill certain strains of lawn grass, like St. Augustine, a reasonably common grass. As such, these lawns, instead of being weed-free, can instead turn brown, undoing all of a homeowner’s hard work. Southern Ag, however, will leave your lawn perfectly intact while attacking a wide variety of broad leaf weeds that may otherwise plague your lawn.

Amine weed killer also comes in a concentrate, meaning that you’ll have to mix it yourself, but it will cover a wide swath of lawn for a lower cost than other types of weed killers. You can also up the concentration of this weed killer if it doesn’t seem like the weeds in your lawn are succumbing to Southern Ag’s efforts. A higher concentration of ag 24d amine weed killer won’t damage your beautiful grass but will instead work hard to keep weeds that have already sprouted in your yard at bay.

It’s worth noting, of course, that you may need to use this weed killer in combination with other brands or Southern Ag products in order to attack the root systems of the weeds in your yard, but superficially, Southern Ag 2.4-D Amine will get the job done.

Pros
  • Will avoid popular grass strains like St. Augustine- which other weed killers may not.
  • Extremely effective at differentiating between weeds and grass.
Cons
  • Won’t kill all common weeds
  • just a majority of popular ones.
  • Kill weeds

Southern Ag 2, 4 - D Amine Weed Killer

3. Ortho Groundclear Vegetation Killer Concentrate – Best Systemic Weed and Grass Killer

Ortho GroundClear Vegetation Killer Concentrate

  • Non-selective, systemic, for use with post- and pre-emergent weeds.

Groundclear vegetation killer concentrate is extremely strong, and with with a formula of non-selective, systemic weed killer, you’ll be able to beat back all kinds of weeds and grass, both pre- and post-emergent. With post-emergent weeds, you’ll see results relatively quickly, but it will also work behind the scenes and embed itself into the root system, killing it from the ground up. Even better, the mixture is intended to keep weeds at bay for up to one year, though in areas with heavy rainfall, you may need to reapply after six to eight months.

Because Ortho vegetation killer concentrate does not exist, and it is extremely poisonous to all kinds of plants, it’s suggested for use only on hard surfaces, such as walkways, driveways, and patios. It’s extremely important to keep Ortho groundclear vegetation killer concentrate away from vegetables, flowers, and other non-lawn growth, because it can contaminate the soil indefinitely, preventing you from being able to grow decorative foliage for a significant amount of time.

Pros
  • Deals with both pre- and post-emergent weeds.
  • Lasts for up to a year.
  • Weed control
Cons
  • Coverage can only be achieved for limited areas.
  • Extremely non-selective.
  • Not for plants

Ortho GroundClear Vegetation Killer Concentrate

4. Bayer Advanced – Best Post-Emergent Lawn Weed and Crabgrass Killer

Bayer Advanced Lawn Weed and Crabgrass Killer

  • Selective, systemic, for use with post-emergent weeds.
  • Prevent new weeds.

Bayer advanced allinone lawn weed is a well-known name in the lawn care industry. As such, their weed killer is a widely recognized and lauded brand, considered some of the best weed killers available. This weed and crabgrass killer, in particular, is considered to be exceptionally effective. One of its selling points is that it kills over  200 different broad leaf weed species. Bayers advanced lawn weed works by invading the root systems of the different weeds it works against quickly and efficiently to spread through their root systems and stunt their growth, both killing the plants that have already emerged and working to prevent future infestations. It’s especially useful against crabgrass. That means that if you’re dealing with a crabgrass infestation, Bayer advanced allinone lawn weed is definitely the way to go.

While it is a concentrate, it has extremely specific instructions. These must be followed to the letter, even more than most weed killers. This will ensure that it doesn’t hurt your lawn or other plants that it shouldn’t affect. As such, think carefully about what weeds in your lawn that you’re trying to kill and make sure to aim it appropriately. Keep an eye on the weather, as well, before you go out and use this weed killer. Any run off that carries Bayer with it may have a negative impact on your broader lawn and the lawns of your neighbors, if you live in a close-set community.

Pros
  • Incredibly effective for crabgrass.
  • Won’t hurt your lawn while dealing with infestations.
  • Killer Selective
  • Brush Killer
Cons
  • Instructions are fairly complex- and must be followed to the letter
  • comparensaves concentrate grass.

BioAdvanced All-in-One Lawn Weed & Crabgrass Killer

5. Roundups Weed and Grass Killer Concentrate Plus – Fast acting vegetation killer

Roundup Weed and Grass Killer Concentrate plus

  • Non-selective, contact and systemic, for use with post-emergent weeds.

Roundup is one of the most popular brands of weed killers available to date, which is why we have two of its best weed killers included on this list. While this listed weed killer is fairly similar to the one we noted before it, it has a few distinct and important differences. To begin, Roundup control is intended for use both as a preventative measure to be taken against weeds and a weed solution. Use Roundup on your lawn before weeds sprout, and you will have ensured that any infestation is weaker than it would have been otherwise. Because Roundup is non-selective, though, you’ll need to look at its chemical makeup in order to determine whether or not it will prevent any of your landscaped plants from growing.

You can then use Roundup if you notice any weeds popping up over the course of spring and summer, as it will still attack the weeds from the outside and ensure that you’re left with a green and beautiful lawn. However, Roundup when used as a post-emergent weed solution, will be slow to attack a weed’s root system, which means that you may have to used this weed killer in combination with other products later in the year.

Roundup also comes pre-mixed and with its own spray cap, making it exceptionally easy to use in a market where most require that you do the mixing and applying yourself. This does, however, make it much more expensive per square foot than most concentrated kinds. Again, though, the benefit of Roundup comes in it’s low-hassle use and spraying pr sq ft. As with most other pre-emergent sprays, we recommend that you stick to hard surfaces when using this weed killer as opposed to your broader lawn, as it will be more effective in these areas when helps you control weeds.

Pros
  • Very effective for all kinds of vegetation.
  • Quick-acting; contact results are visible within about 12 hours.
Cons
  • More expensive than some similar products.

Roundup Weed and Grass Killer Concentrate Plus

 

6. Roundup – Best Grass Killer Plus Pre and Post Weed Control

Roundup Control Weed and Grass Killer

  • Non-selective, contact and systemic, for use with pre- and post-emergent weeds

This solution is extremely similar to the above, but it has a few important differences. First of all, it’s intended for use both as a preventative measure and a weed solution. You can use it before weeds sprout, and then again if you find them popping up. It also comes pre-mixed, with its own spray cap. This makes it much more expensive per square foot than the concentrate, but takes away most of the hassle of mixing and spraying pr sq ft. As with most pre-emergent sprays, you should stick to hard surfaces with this one.

Pros
  • Kills weeds both existing and non-germinated seeds.
  • Easy and quick to use.
Cons
  • Much more expensive for the ease of use.

Roundup Extended Control Weed & Grass Killer Plus Weed Preventer

7. Preen Garden – Best  Selective Garden Weed Preventer

Preen Garden Weed Preventer

  • Selective, systemic, for use with pre-emergent weeds.

This is strictly for use as a weed preventer. With Preen, you get a carton of granules with a spreader power cap. You then spread them over your lawn when weeds are about to start sprouting. Then, you reapply at the turn of the season, about every 9-12 weeks.

The best thing about this preventative weed killer is exactly how selective it is. It prevents twenty-seven types of broadleaf weeds, while ignoring over 200 types of flowers, bulbs, shrubs, trees, and vegetables! While it is more expensive than some other products in the same group, it definitely lives up to its price.

Pros
  • Extremely well-known pre-emergent product.
  • Very effective for most weeds- while avoiding most foliage.
Cons
  • More expensive than competing products.

Preen 283894 Garden Weed Preventer

8. Gordon’s SpeedZone Lawn Weed Killer – Selective Fast Acting

Gordon’s SpeedZone Lawn Weed Killer

  • Selective, contact, for use with post-emergent weeds.

One of the biggest pulls of this weed killer is how incredibly effective it is; it targets over 100 different species of broad-leaf weeds. Another perk is that it’s incredibly concentrated. Just twenty ounces can make over twenty gallons, giving you an incredible amount of coverage. Even with the recommendation to reapply every two to six weeks, it’s very effective.

However, even as a selective weed killer, it still targets St. Augustine grass. It may also target certain kinds of aesthetically pleasing clovers.

Pros
  • Extremely effective; results are visible within one to two weeks.
  • Works very well in cold climates.
  • Effective Weed Killer
  • Great for woody plants
Cons
  • Not suitable for certain kinds of lawn grass

PBI/Gordon 652400 Speed Zone Lawn Weed Killer

9. Scotts Halts Crabgrass & Grassy Weed Preventer (Best Total Vegetation Killer)

Scotts Halts Crabgrass & Grassy Weed Preventer

  • Selective, systemic, for use with pre-emergent weeds.

If you’re looking for an extremely effective preemptive solution, it’s hard to go wrong with Scott Halts. This solution uses a strong herbicide to keep weeds from growing. Simply add it to the lawn before weeds sprout, and it will keep them at bay for at least twelve weeks. However, the recommendation is to apply twice per year.

This product is so powerful, though, that it will not allow you to plant anything else for four months after you apply it. That includes plants that are not affected once they’ve already germinated. It also won’t affect any weeds that have already sprouted.

Pros
  • Easy application.
  • Kills existing weeds
  • Great to stop weeds before they sprout. Well-priced.
Cons
  • Can’t plant absolutely any other plants for about four months after application.

Scotts Halts Crabgrass & Grassy Weed Preventer

10. Spectracide Weed Killer for Lawns (Grass Killer Concentrate plus Weed Control)

Spectracide Weed Stop for Lawns

  • Selective, systemic, for use with post-emergent weeds.
  • Kills the weed – Plus weed preventer

If you want a weed killer to tackle your weed issues, but you also want something more gentle on your existing plants, you’ll love Spectracide weed stop. This formula kills over 200 weed species, while leaving your grass and plants untouched, even if you accidentally miss your mark. There are a few grass species that they mention avoiding with this product, but it’s very safe for most species.

Pros
  • Consistently targets weeds- not lawns.
  • Very gentle on lawns and other unaffected plants.
  • Extended Control
  • Weed killer for lawn
Cons
  • It takes longer to see results — about three weeks
  • a week longer than most weed killers.

Spectracide Weed Stop For Lawns Concentrate

Other popular organic weed killers include Scotts turf builder weed and feed, southern ag crossbow weed and bush killer, chickweed clover, crossbow specialty and avenger organics that are helpful in growing a great flower beds and preventing weeds grasses.

Conclusion

There are different types of weed killers. Whether you’re looking to replant, trying to fix your weed problem, or even just starting an entirely new project, these weed killers are easily the best way to go about it. There’s an option for every problem, so you can keep the weeds out of your lawn.

Related Post:

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 3 comments